• 
  Jake Kitchin

   Young Gianmarco (16 episodes, 2016-2017)
• 
  Gianmarco Soresi

   Gianmarco / ... (16 episodes, 2016-2017)
• 
  Megan Sass

  Cassandra
• 
  Thomas Wesson

  Ethan
• 
  Douglas Goodhart

  Hasidic Husband
• 
  Alex Estrada

  Alex
• 
  Alice Grindling

  Alice
• 
  Mauricio Marcés

  Nick

• 
  Dominique Nisperos

  Dominique
• 
  Sarah Seeds

  Natalie
• 
  Garrett Gray

  Clint
• 
  Cristina Pitter

  Nora
• 
  Jonathan Braylock

  Jesus Christ
• 
  Sarah Burke

  Sarah the Hip Hop Instructor
• 
  Chris Cafero

  George

• 
  Chris Rice

  Christopher
• 
  Bess Fifer

  Bess the Casting Director
• 
  Lindsay-Elizabeth Hand

  Lindsay