• 
  Shay Mitchell

  Nicole
• 
  Jason Schwartzman

  Peter
• 
  Robin Thomas

  Allen
• 
  Alan Ruck

  Walter
• 
  Talia Shire

  Victoria
• 
  Lilli Birdsell

  Heather
• 
  Parisa Fakhri

  Client #2
• 
  Nick Thune

  Jason

• 
  Brittany Furlan

  Emily
• 
  Noël Wells

  Joanna
• 
  Sara Coates

  Client #1
• 
  Frankie J. Allison

  Heather's Husband
• 
  Amy Landecker

  Olivia
• 
  Elizabeth Ruscio

  Joyce
• 
  Frankie Shaw

  Lizzie

• 
  Sarah Schubert

  Receptionist
• 
  Leon Martell

  Priest
• 
  William Schwartzman

  David (as William M. Schwartzman)
• 
  Johnny Simmons

  Monty Fagan