• 
  Melissa Moore

   Herself (unknown episodes)
• 
  Isa Nichols

   Herself (1 episode, 2015)
• 
  Jill Sheimo

   Victim (1 episode, 2017)
• 
  Rick Trevisani

   Victim (1 episode, 2017)
• 
  Abraham Luna

  1 episode, 2017
• 
  Ryan Peker

  1 episode, 2017
• 
  Sue Doman

  Self - Sister of Kathleen Savio
• 
  Pamela Ortiz

  Miguel's Wife

• 
  Drew Peterson

  Self
• 
  Stephen Peterson

  Self - Drew's Son
• 
  Kathleen Savio

  Self
• 
  Cindy Brown

  Self
• 
  Shelly Ramirez

  Self - niece of Richard Ramirez
• 
  Randy Hausner

  Self
• 
  Sitora Yusufiy

  Self

• 
  Tonya Beasley

  Self