• 
  Greg Kinnear
• 
  Jennifer Grey

  Rita Schwerner
• 
  CCH Pounder

  Fannie Lee Chaney
• 
  Elizabeth Omilami

  Charlies Wife
• 
  Blair Underwood

  James Chaney
• 
  Tom Hulce

  Mickey Schwerner
• 
  Andre Braugher

  Dennis
• 
  Royce D. Applegate

  Deputy Winter

• 
  Afemo Omilami

  Bob Moses
• 
  Josh Charles

  Andrew Goodman
• 
  J. Don Ferguson
• 
  John Dennis Johnston

  Hatchet-faced man
• 
  Eugene Byrd

  Ben Jr
• 
  Thom Gossom Jr.

  Charlie Parham
• 
  Ray McKinnon

  Lyle's father

• 
  Scott Lawrence
• 
  Ted Manson

  Wilbur Combs
• 
  Harry Caesar

  Hollis Watkins
• 
  Walton Goggins

  Lyle
• 
  Tom Nowicki

  Sam