• 
  Evan Boymel

  Louis 'Lepke' Buchalter
• 
  Taylor M. Graham

  Genovese's Mobster
• 
  Ian Bell

  Meyer Lansky
• 
  James Kacey

  Joe Bonanno (as Giuseppe Penasso)
• 
  Anthony Bisciello

  Joe Profaci
• 
  Umberto Celisano

  Al Capone
• 
  Rich Graff

  Lucky Luciano
• 
  Carl Drake

  Detective

• 
  Roberto De Felice

  Salvatore Maranzano
• 
  James Davenjay

  Pete La Tempa
• 
  Anthony DiCarlo

  Frank Costello
• 
  Erik Decicco

  Joseph Valachi
• 
  John Jarvis

  High Roller
• 
  Marco Di Giuseppe

  Lucky Luciano's Bodyguard
• 
  Dom DiMercurio

  Speak Easy Mobster

• 
  John Paul Andrews

  Masseria's Thug