• 
  Brian Foreman

  Grieving Widower
• 
  Noah Forrest

  Carlo Gambino
• 
  John Paul Andrews

  Gangster
• 
  Cody Bennett

  Gangster
• 
  Richard Adams

  Ralph the Booker
• 
  Anthony Bisciello

  Joe Profaci
• 
  Evan Boymel

  Louis 'Lepke' Buchalter
• 
  James Davenjay

  Pete La Tempa

• 
  Anthony DiCarlo

  Frank Costello
• 
  Carl Drake

  Detective
• 
  John C. Bailey

  George M. Scanlon
• 
  Ian Bell

  Meyer Lansky
• 
  Umberto Celisano

  Al Capone
• 
  Rich Graff

  Lucky Luciano
• 
  Dom DiMercurio

  Lead Hitman Who Shot Willie Moretti

• 
  Frank DiNovi

  Young Lucky Luciano
• 
  Dominique Bela

  Alice