• 
  Erik Nelson

  John Newton
• 
  Lunden De'Leon

  Aminata
• 
  Carl I. Johnson

  Sailor
• 
  David Lowe

  Priest & Doctor
• 
  Jim McKeny

  Mr. Chapman
• 
  Rachel Saint

  Alexandria Watson
• 
  Rob Springer

  Samuel Watson (Adult)
• 
  Lilly Nelson

  Bar Wench

• 
  Tom Hagan

  Sailor
• 
  W. Scott Parker III

  Captain Philip Carteret
• 
  Darron Slagle

  Tribesman
• 
  Celina Tolbert

  Mary Catlett (Young)
• 
  Quinten Johnson

  Tribesman
• 
  Kevin Gerrior

  Ship's Doctor
• 
  Brad Corbin

  First Mate (Harwitch)

• 
  Mark Kilby

  Captain Gother
• 
  Edison Skinner

  Billy Prowse
• 
  Landon Wall

  Samuel Watson
• 
  Marianne Geyer

  Mrs. Catlett
• 
  Susan L. Jones

  Mary Newton
• 
  J.W. Burris

  Angus Campbell
• 
  Cameo Crumby

  Slave
• 
  Folaranmi Afolayan

  Peyai
• 
  Spyder MacDonald

  Captain Phelps
• 
  Desmond Howard

  Mustapha
• 
  Jeremy Degree

  Guard
• 
  Malcolm Evans

  Tribesman
• 
  Amber Dawn Fox

  Newton's Mother
• 
  Trey Riley

  Tribesman
• 
  Dave Ross

  Tribesman
• 
  Tara Whitney Riso

  Girl on Beach
• 
  Andre Price Jr.

  Slave
• 
  Sara E. Butner

  Mary Newton at 35
• 
  Tate Lewis

  John Newton as child
• 
  Paul Rainville

  Slave
• 
  Carter Gentle

  Bullied Cabin Boy
• 
  Aaron Cameron

  Sailor 1
• 
  Bryan Canam

  Sailor
• 
  Justin Desmond

  Slave
• 
  Joshua Fifield

  John as Cabin Boy
• 
  Ryan Gero

  Slave
• 
  Michael Hotson

  George - Sailor on Warship
• 
  Wyatt MacPhail

  Sailor
• 
  Tyler Nugent

  Sailor
• 
  Matthew Fifield

  Young John #2
• 
  Barry Randle

  Ship's Cook