• 
  Katie Lyons

   Katie Smith (2 episodes, 2013)
• 
  Amelia Watkins

   Amy Weaver (2 episodes, 2013)
• 
  Timothy S. Quigley

   Father David Anderson (4 episodes, 2013)
• 
  Michele Quigley

   Ruthie Stoltzfus (4 episodes, 2013)
• 
  Laura Bakin

   Frances Callahan (3 episodes, 2013)
• 
  Dominic Spadea

   Monsignor Cletus Wagman (2 episodes, 2013)
• 
  Chris Quigley

   Josh Anderson (4 episodes, 2013)
• 
  Matt Watkins

   Mister Cesar Debus (2 episodes, 2013)

• 
  Jacob Watkins

   Phil Dunn (3 episodes, 2013)
• 
  Matthew Quigley

   Young Josh (2 episodes, 2013)
• 
  Peter Quigley

   Young David (2 episodes, 2013)
• 
  Mary Frances Blum

   Jill Johnson (2 episodes, 2013)
• 
  Christian Legaspi

   Phil Smith (2 episodes, 2013)
• 
  Brendan Lyons

   Brendan Smith (2 episodes, 2013)
• 
  Caleb Bressler

   John Jacob Fleming (2 episodes, 2013)

• 
  Katie Lyons

   Katie Smith (2 episodes, 2013)