• 
  Jon Voight

  Ben Crowley
• 
  Philip Boyd

  Sheriff Jake Givens
• 
  Vail Bloom

  Caroline Crowley
• 
  Alexa Nisenson

  Shelly
• 
  Eva LaRue

  Marta Jenkins
• 
  Phil Russell

  Veterinarian
• 
  Scott Summitt

  Gerald Jenkins
• 
  Isabella Blake-Thomas

  Young Caroline

• 
  Robert Thompson

  Doctor
• 
  Mercedes Carter

  Young Caroline
• 
  Dallas Edwards

  Grocery Boy
• 
  Amiya Harris

  Mahogany (Foster Sister #2)
• 
  Mary Charles H. Miller

  Caitlyn
• 
  Brooks Roseberry

  Brooks (Foster Brother)
• 
  Isabel Young

  Young Shelly

• 
  Trisha Curry

  Melissa (voice)
• 
  Sarah East

  Shelly's Mom
• 
  Tracy Oliver

  Tracy Oliver / Wolf Trainer (credit only)
• 
  Journey Bishop

  Lucy
• 
  Jessica Childers

  Officer in Prison
• 
  Andrea Ahl

  Rendering Service Lady
• 
  Niklaus Hall

  Animal Rendering Serviceman 1 (as Nicklaus Hall)
• 
  Elizabeth Blake-Thomas

  Ben's Wife
• 
  Bobby Pavlick

  Animal Rendering Serviceman 2