• 
  Jess Cagle

  1 episode, 2018
• 
  Theresa Croft

  1 episode, 2018
• 
  Anna Andersen

  1 episode, 2018
• 
  Dan Wakeford

  1 episode, 2018
• 
  Roger Hervas

  1 episode
• 
  Sly Augustus

  1 episode
• 
  Shady Kerko

  1 episode, 2019
• 
  Alexandra Rose Krieger

  1 episode, 2019

• 
  Julia Cusworth

  1 episode, 2019
• 
  Lori Bodinizzo

  1 episode, 2019
• 
  Kathryn Kuhn

  1 episode, 2019
• 
  Claire Burgi

  1 episode, 2019
• 
  Davide Illiano

  1 episode, 2019
• 
  Estelle Girard Parks

  1 episode, 2019
• 
  Julian Mileta

  1 episode, 2019

• 
  Janine Hartmann

  1 episode
• 
  Dennis Connors

  1 episode, 2018
• 
  Elana Valastro

  1 episode, 2019
• 
  Carl Burrows

  1 episode, 2019
• 
  Ashlee Voorsanger

  1 episode, 2019
• 
  Seamus Higgins

  1 episode, 2018
• 
  Clayton Grimm

  1 episode, 2019
• 
  Dana Zurkowski

  1 episode, 2019
• 
  Shonnon Marshall

  1 episode, 2018
• 
  Elle Herson

  1 episode, 2019
• 
  Katelynn Kennedy Staggs

  1 episode, 2019
• 
  Ilir Fiora

  1 episode, 2019
• 
  Beka Burlak

  1 episode, 2019
• 
  Nathalie Frederick

  1 episode, 2019
• 
  Alicia Ocana

  1 episode, 2019
• 
  Nancy Marlowe Gordon

   Angela Smith
• 
  Kyle Pierce

   Cultist
• 
  Paige Felger

   Young Jemima
• 
  Samantha Wendorf

   Younger Julie
• 
  Sam Gray

   Vicenta
• 
  Omrae Smith

  Ruby's Mother
• 
  Ilir Fiora

  Male Cultist
• 
  Bobby Páraknight

  Tex Watson
• 
  Ashley Van Egeren

  Cult Member