• 
  Dean Cameron

  Talk Radio skeptic (voice)
• 
  Stuart Fratkin

  Karl's Dad
• 
  Ellie Church

  Ellie
• 
  Conrad Brooks

  UFO Spotter
• 
  Bryan Wilson

  Dr. F
• 
  Raymond Kester

  Ron
• 
  Jason Hignite

  Mr. Hinkle
• 
  Brigid Macaulay

  Witch Queen

• 
  Chuck Terrell

  Major Confusion
• 
  Jordan Campbell

  Karl
• 
  Karla Guzman

  Eve
• 
  Jennifer Battaglia

  Nosey Neighbor
• 
  Karen East

  Caricature Lady
• 
  Sky Truth

  Frankensteins Babe
• 
  Corey Miller

  Snack Bar Guy

• 
  Elizabeth Brehob

  Amy
• 
  John East

  John
• 
  Christian Kelly

  Creepy Caretaker
• 
  Shay Dickerhoff

  The Monster
• 
  Eric Schroeder

  German Guy
• 
  Scott Orr

  Universal President of the Earth
• 
  Branden Yates

  Don
• 
  Ken Shriver

  General Hanover
• 
  Eric Jones

  Caricature Thief
• 
  Rachel East

  Ghostly Figure
• 
  D.C. Eikleberry

  Talk Radio Personality
• 
  Jason Newlin

  Jason
• 
  Bob East

  Slasher
• 
  Athena Prychodko

  Pillow Fight Girl
• 
  Roni Jonah

  Pillow Fight Girl
• 
  Shay Baker

  The Monster
• 
  Julie Streble

  Pillow Fight Girl
• 
  Julia Dillman

  Pillow Fight Girl
• 
  Lucretia Lynn

  Pillow Fight Girl
• 
  Piotr Michael

  Vincent Price (voice)
• 
  Samantha Michelle

  Erika