• 
  Allison Lobel

  Abigail Rodriguez
• 
  Romel De Silva

  Lord Michael Gayagay
• 
  Marilyn Flores

  LGBT Support (Pie Fight)
• 
  Sirena Yang

  LGBT Support (Pie Fight)
• 
  Michaela Kahan

  Kari
• 
  Taurean Cavins-Flores

  Albert Rodriguez
• 
  Bethany Koulias

  Pat
• 
  Matt Jennings

  Lawrence Berry

• 
  Levi Austin Morris

  David Martin
• 
  Emerson Gregori

  Samuel Hicks
• 
  Ashley DeMatteo

  Jessica Gayagay
• 
  Theodore Coonradt

  Ted Lucas
• 
  Alexandra Fream

  Darla Smith
• 
  Lauren Moss

  Terri
• 
  Nathaniel Nuñez

  LGBT Club Attendee

• 
  Chyka Jackson

  LGBT Support (Pie Fight)
• 
  Victoria Martonne

  LGBT Support (Pie Fight)
• 
  Sydney Anthony

  Townsperson
• 
  Sean Sekino

  Pied Crew Member
• 
  Paula Lauzon

  Choir Singer
• 
  Andrea Unruh Sovern

  Townsperson / LGBT Support
• 
  Sarnica Lim

  LGBT Club Attendee
• 
  Lauren Moss

  Terri
• 
  Michael Barlow

  Townsperson
• 
  Weston Meredith

  Brian Cross
• 
  Daniella Mora-Balbo

  Press Conference Attendee
• 
  Conner Floyd

  Press Conference Attendee
• 
  Kyle Felleman

  Press Conference Attendee
• 
  Orlena Hart

  Choir Singer
• 
  Mitch Shatzen

  Choir Member
• 
  Mike Barnard

  Townsperson (Restaurant)
• 
  Angelica Neece

  LGBT Support (Pie Fight)
• 
  Hector Chavez

  Multiple Characters
• 
  William Mack

  Guenter (Weeping Crew Member)
• 
  Perry Lobel

  Priest