• 
  Jenn Gotzon

  Cheerleading Instructor
• 
  Irene Santiago

  Edith
• 
  Anita Cordell

  Bridesmaid
• 
  Rich Swingle

  Adult Mitchell
• 
  LaQuita Chantelle James

  Speech contestant's sister
• 
  A. Michelle Harleston

  Fashion model
• 
  Thom Booton

  Male Model
• 
  Lanny Smith

  Blind date

• 
  Courtney Lee Simpson

  Poor mom
• 
  Brianna Beaton

  Speech contestant
• 
  Rebekah Cook

  Journalism Teacher
• 
  Stacey Bradshaw

  Teen Rachel
• 
  Brenda Jo Reutebuch

  Grieving woman
• 
  Hayden Gael Barnes

  Poor child
• 
  Juli Tapken

  Adult Rachel

• 
  Chase Anderson

  Young Mitchell
• 
  Melissa Pinkston

  Grieving Girl
• 
  Marcy Conway

  Bridesmaid
• 
  Joy Whitten

  Teen girl at swing
• 
  Tucker Meek

  Bully Boy
• 
  Mary Meyer

  Teacher
• 
  Priscilla Wittman

  Mourner
• 
  Elias Jo'el

  Amy's boyfriend
• 
  Hudson Meek

  Bully boy
• 
  Amiya Harris

  Speech contestant's sister
• 
  Loran Bolding

  Teacher
• 
  Julianne Fincher

  Todd's New Girlfriend
• 
  Missy Crowder-Compton

  Church Member
• 
  Katie Pavao

  Amy
• 
  Ray Graham

  Arguing couple
• 
  Emily Knapp

  Young Rachel
• 
  Nathan Jacobson

  Todd
• 
  Caia England

  Wedding Guest
• 
  Amelia Mann

  Newspaper Staff member
• 
  Madyson Erwin

  Cute girl with bunny
• 
  Lacy Garrison

  Beautiful woman
• 
  Lee Ann Maloney

  Nurse
• 
  Bailey Dozier

  Girl at Park
• 
  Apolonia Davalos

  Beautiful woman at church