• 
  Warner Baxter

  Joaquin Murrieta
• 
  Bruce Cabot

  Bill Warren
• 
  Carlos De Valdez

  José Murrieta (as Carlos de Valdez)
• 
  Kay Hughes

  Louise
• 
  Soledad Jiménez

  Madre Murrieta (as Soledad Jimenez)
• 
  Edgar Kennedy

  Sheriff Judd
• 
  Eric Linden

  Johnnie 'Jack' Warren
• 
  Ann Loring

  Señorita Juanita de la Cuesta

• 
  Margo

  Rosa F. 'Rosita' de Murrieta
• 
  Francis McDonald

  Pedro
• 
  J. Carrol Naish

  Three Fingered Jack
• 
  George Regas

  Tomás
• 
  Ralph Remley

  Judge Hank Perkins
• 
  Harvey Stephens

  Capt. Osborne
• 
  Charles Trowbridge

  Ramon de la Cuesta