• 
  Julie Chapin

  2 episodes, 2018-2019
• 
  Julia Boyes

   Brook Weber (reinactment) (1 episode, 2017)
• 
  Lucy Dolly Caires

   Detective Beverly Reinhold (1 episode, 2017)
• 
  Kaylin Hedges

   Young elisa (1 episode, 2017)
• 
  Paskiel Wolfe

   Himself - Jeffrey's Father (1 episode, 2017)
• 
  Brook Weber

   Herself - Survivor (1 episode, 2017)
• 
  Lee Merrill

   Himself - Detective (1 episode, 2017)
• 
  Elisa Jones

   Herself - Daughter (1 episode, 2017)

• 
  Bev Reinhold

   Herself - Detective (1 episode, 2017)
• 
  Mindy Renee Jaffar

   Herself - Daughter (1 episode, 2017)
• 
  Joyce Wood

   Herself - Mother (1 episode, 2017)
• 
  Jan Pharr

   Herself - Congregant (1 episode, 2017)
• 
  Keith Santagata

   Himself - Detective (1 episode, 2017)
• 
  Philip Schaefer

  1 episode, 2017
• 
  Nickolas Wolf

  1 episode, 2017

• 
  Tyler Pino

  1 episode, 2017
• 
  Erich Schuett

  1 episode, 2017
• 
  Tara Rose Schreiber

  1 episode, 2017
• 
  Samuel Shurtleff

  1 episode, 2017
• 
  Christian Dimarzio

  1 episode, 2017
• 
  Christine J. Carlson

  1 episode, 2017
• 
  Donal Brophy

  1 episode, 2017
• 
  Ed McGlynn

  1 episode, 2017
• 
  Mari Hayes

  1 episode, 2017
• 
  Connor Hawke

  1 episode, 2017
• 
  Leonydus Johnson

  1 episode, 2017
• 
  Shelly Harding

  1 episode, 2017
• 
  Dave Schlegel

  1 episode, 2017
• 
  Susan Ison

  1 episode, 2017
• 
  Karen Thomas

  1 episode, 2017
• 
  Mark Hitch

  1 episode, 2017
• 
  Robert Steckel

  1 episode, 2017
• 
  Elaine Rice

  1 episode, 2017
• 
  John McCarthy

  1 episode, 2017
• 
  Tiffani Horn

  1 episode, 2017
• 
  James Zeiss

  1 episode, 2017
• 
  Christopher Gonzalez

  1 episode, 2017
• 
  Alexandra Sherer

  1 episode, 2019
• 
  Tom Voytek

  1 episode, 2019
• 
  Tom Wendling

  1 episode, 2019
• 
  Deborah Finley

  1 episode, 2019
• 
  Matthew Gochman

  1 episode, 2019
• 
  Billy Brannigan

  1 episode, 2019
• 
  Max MacKenzie

  1 episode, 2019
• 
  Hannah Eakin

  1 episode, 2018
• 
  Courtney Gonzalez

  1 episode
• 
  Matt Maragno

  1 episode, 2019
• 
  Bob Leszczak

  1 episode, 2018
• 
  Silvestro Rubino

  1 episode, 2019
• 
  Brooke Koffler

  1 episode, 2019
• 
  Brian Vadim

  2 episodes, 2018-2019
• 
  Paul Noonan

  Det. Minor's Partner
• 
  Bill Mellen

  Detective Terry Jensen
• 
  Brandi McClain

  Self - Friend
• 
  Ken Taylor

  Self - Debbie Taylor's Husband
• 
  Richard Huffman

  Self - Brother
• 
  Jo Lynn Mulcahy

  Self - Investigator
• 
  Greg Hiemann

  Self - Son
• 
  Gary Fortin

  Self - Detective
• 
  Donda Peterson

  Self - Mother
• 
  Mark Meister

  Self - Detective
• 
  Karen Hull

  Self - Walter Aackerson's Mother
• 
  Ivy Lanthier

  Self - Counselor
• 
  Brandon Lafferty

  Lamar Lafferty's Son
• 
  Marty Thomas

  Donald Ellis Thomas' Sister
• 
  Robert Owen

  Self - Deputy, Clarke County MS Sheriff's Office
• 
  Terry Jensen

  Self - Investigator
• 
  Auggie Costantino

  Self - Minister
• 
  Rachael Phillips

  Self - Friend
• 
  Amber Daniels

  Self - Survivor
• 
  Mike Harlin

  Self - Deputy
• 
  Aaron Gillum

  Self - Survivor
• 
  Stephen Sorrell

  Self - Vice Principal
• 
  Jeff Martin

  Self - Captian
• 
  Carl Fox

  Self - District Attorney
• 
  LeAnn Davis

  Self - Survivor
• 
  Amy Fuller

  Self - Leann's Daughter
• 
  Larry Schlegel

  Self - Son
• 
  John McKillop

  Self - Sergeant
• 
  Will Currie

  Self - Detective
• 
  Bruno Pascale

  officer
• 
  Teri Banks

  Self - Survivor
• 
  Al Bodnar

  Self - Survivor
• 
  Ron Cole

  Self - Lieutenant, SCSD
• 
  Faun Ward

  Self - Cousin
• 
  Tom Brennan

  Self - Detective
• 
  Linda Hardin

  Self - Wife
• 
  Jay Williams

  Self - Spokane Resident
• 
  Gene McGougan

  Self - Lietenant
• 
  Julia Harmia

  Self - Victim
• 
  Danny Cooper

  Self - Lieutenant
• 
  Juanita Kirkwood

  Self - Wife
• 
  Lori Holland

  Self - Niece
• 
  Phyllis McCallum

  Self - Jacob H. J. Langworthy's Grandmother
• 
  Scott Tummond

  Self - Lt., Levy County FL Sheriff's Office
• 
  Debra Teerlink

  Self - Michael Hill's Mother
• 
  Rob McCreery

  Self - Brother
• 
  Geri Much

  Self - Mother
• 
  Jasmine Albarran

  Self - Daughter
• 
  Kim Harris

  Self - Ex-Wife
• 
  Michael Kermon

  Self - Patrol Officer
• 
  Margaret Carvour

  Self - Erin Alexander Halk's Mother
• 
  Rick Cautela

  Bartender, Alrosa Villa Nightclub - Survivor
• 
  Jeff Tharp

  Self - Chief of Police
• 
  Shauna Schallert

  Self - Sister
• 
  Cindy Marlow

  Self - Mother
• 
  James Niggemeyer

  Self - Ofc., Columbus OH Police Department
• 
  Ed Bergtold

  Robert Kimbrew
• 
  Paul Darren Varricchio

  Lieutenant Gene Mcgougan
• 
  Kerry Britt

  Boontem Anderson
• 
  Robert Kimbrew

  Self - Tina Kimbrew's Father
• 
  Barry Macha

  Self - District Attorney
• 
  Albert Dubinsky

  Deputy
• 
  Jennifer Taylor

  Self - Ken & Debbie Taylor's Daughter
• 
  Jessica Miller

  Self - Daughter
• 
  Mara Beier

  Mindy
• 
  Justin M. Tolliver

  Older Richie
• 
  Bobby Paul

  Ken's Boss
• 
  Sherri Bevan Walsh

  Self - Prosecutor
• 
  Hayes Minor

  Self - Police Chief
• 
  Alexandra Küas

  Lori
• 
  Jordan Allen Bell

  Friend wearing wire
• 
  Mika Moulton

  Self - Mother
• 
  Amy Harrison

  Self - Survivor
• 
  Matt Whitfield

  Detective
• 
  Meghan Lane

  Deb
• 
  Alec Tincher

  Jeff Grote