• 
  Claudette Colbert

  Lydia Kenyon
• 
  Ray Milland

  Tony Kenyon
• 
  Armand Kaliz

  Jeweler
• 
  Mona Barrie

  Charlette Gorell
• 
  James Flavin

  Subway guard
• 
  May Boley

  Fat woman in subway car
• 
  Grant Mitchell

  Frederick Vantine
• 
  Hobart Cavanaugh

  Small man in subway car

• 
  Irving Bacon

  Ferryman
• 
  John G. Jones

  Tony Kenyon
• 
  Binnie Barnes

  Myrtle Vantine
• 
  Frank Orth

  Subway cashier
• 
  Francisco Maran

  Harrison (travel agent)
• 
  Brian Aherne

  Jim Blake
• 
  Edward Fielding

  Scholarly man in subway car

• 
  Walter Abel

  George Gore