• 
  Jerry Pelletier

  4 episodes, 2018
• 
  Katherine Ramsland

  Self
• 
  Kent Booker

   Attorney (2 episodes, 2017)
• 
  Betty Krachey

   Bar Girl-Extra / ... (2 episodes, 2017)
• 
  Daniel Luce

  2 episodes
• 
  Linda Wiegand

  2 episodes, 2017
• 
  Blake Rice Kirkland

  2 episodes, 2018
• 
  Donovan Corneetz

  3 episodes, 2018

• 
  Tommy Campbell

  2 episodes, 2018
• 
  Geoffrey Paschel

  2 episodes
• 
  Dan Tippen

  2 episodes, 2018
• 
  Jermaine Carter

  Tupac
• 
  Janine DeMichele Baggett

  Laci Peterson
• 
  Josh DeBord

  Detective
• 
  Rip Elliott

  Young Drew Peterson

• 
  Shelton Foreman

  Detective
• 
  Alvin Gray

  Marion Hugh 'Suge' Knight
• 
  Trina Gregory

  Bar Girl-extra
• 
  Gavin Hensley

  Young Jesperson
• 
  Dana Jay

  Christopher 'Biggie Smalls' Wallace
• 
  James Arthur Williams

  Robber
• 
  Brian Lewis

  Orlando Anderson
• 
  Shawn D. White

  Danny Boy
• 
  Jeremiah Longbear

  DJ (Notorious B.I.G.)
• 
  Mark Valeriano

  Michael Gargiulo
• 
  Bill Hagmaier

  Self
• 
  Erin Bradley Dangar

  Paula Dietz Rader
• 
  Asher Sheets

  Young Charlie Otero
• 
  Sophia Sparks

  Carmen Otero
• 
  Laurie Winkel

  Nancy Fox
• 
  Timothy Sean Worley

  Jury member
• 
  Joshua Cordle

  Ted Bundy
• 
  Kara Brooke

  Teen Kerri Rader