• 
  Kathleen Garrett

  Narrator (voice)
• 
  Kayd Currier

  Killer
• 
  Skoti Collins

  Policeman
• 
  Russell Lee Mills

  Pimp (as Russell Lee Mills)
• 
  Abigail McConnell

  Jennifer Myers
• 
  James Bruchak

  Himself - Pennsylvania State Police (as Trooper James Bruchak)
• 
  Elizabeth Evans

  Herself - York Dispatch
• 
  Jim Maynard

  Himself - Jennifer's Brother

• 
  Kevin Brian Dowling

  Himself - Suspect (archive footage)
• 
  Barb Hayes

  Herself - Jennifer's Sister
• 
  Tim Barker

  Himself - York County District Attorney's Office
• 
  William M. Mowrey

  Himself - Pennsylvania State Police (as Cpl. William M. Mowrey)
• 
  Jennifer Myers

  Herself - Victim (archive footage)
• 
  Robert Boyle

  Himself - Dickinson College (as Professor Robert Boyle)
• 
  Julio Mendez

  Himself - Pennsylvania State Police (as Cpl. Julio Mendez)