• 
  Kathleen Garrett

  Narrator (voice)
• 
  David Hill

  Detective
• 
  Skoti Collins

  Policeman
• 
  Jack Myers

  Himself - Victim (archive footage)
• 
  Timothy Duerr

  Himself - Miami Valley Regional Crime Lab
• 
  Ronald Lee Huston

  Himself - Miami Valley Regional Crime Lab
• 
  Richard Howell

  Himself - Prosecuting Attorney, Drake Co.
• 
  Jennifer Brown

  Herself - Gregg Myers' Former Girlfriend

• 
  Amber Holscher

  Herself - Linda's Granddaughter
• 
  Gregg Myers

  Himself (archive footage)
• 
  Rodney Baker

  Himself - Darke County Sheriff's Office (as Det. Rodney Baker)
• 
  Mike Burns

  Himself - Darke County Sheriff's Office (as Det. Mike Burns)
• 
  Kim Hudelson

  Herself - Linda's Daughter
• 
  Steve Baker

  Himself - Northern Bureau Chief, WHIO-TV
• 
  Dwight A. Edwards

  Himself - Darke County Wildlife Officer