• 
  Pete Schwaba

  Dan Fogelman
• 
  Charlie Lubeck

  Sparks (Justin)
• 
  Sam Raysby

  Agitated train commuter
• 
  William French

  Brad
• 
  Keith Kelly

  Uncle Max
• 
  Clayton Backes

  Mike R
• 
  Peter Nerad

  Dad
• 
  Colleen Mooney

  Maddy

• 
  Ali Abraham

  Anna
• 
  Kelsey Risher

  Sarah Daniels
• 
  Scott Hennelly

  Jake
• 
  William Walton

  Philip
• 
  Tyler Esselman

  Pastor Eli Daniels
• 
  Barbara Malangoni

  Aunt Carol
• 
  Sedra

  Drew

• 
  Megan Caton

  Jennifer (as Megan Caton)
• 
  Joey Bednarski

  Randy
• 
  Mathew Bridges

  Athlete's Friends
• 
  Debbie Brown

  Church Stage Manager
• 
  Garry Crafton

  Man with flowers
• 
  Kyle Culver

  Church Band Guitarist