• 
  Brandon Beets

  Search Party
• 
  Beth Grant

  Ms. Dobbins
• 
  Kai Lennox

  Judge Thatcher
• 
  Gary McDonald

  Muff Potter
• 
  John Marrott

  Pastor Fossey
• 
  Marianna Palka

  Aunt Polly
• 
  Johnny Whitworth

  Dr. Robinson
• 
  Chantal Nchako

  Lisbeth Potter

• 
  Corwin Allard

  Ben Rogers
• 
  James Edwards

  Deputy Jack
• 
  Angelina Capozzoli

  Thomasina Sawyer
• 
  Corey Bente

  Deputy Luke
• 
  Joseph J. Bezenek

  Townsfolk (as J. Vasko-Bezenek)
• 
  Arthur RedCloud

  Joe
• 
  Eva Hauge

  School Girl

• 
  Kahlia Canada

  School Girl
• 
  Silvia Bottini

  Townsfolk
• 
  Joe Olney

  Townsfolk
• 
  Noah Dobson

  Schoolboy
• 
  Jayden Maddux

  George Harper
• 
  William Lipton

  Alfred Thatcher
• 
  Shay Rudolph

  Becky Thatcher
• 
  Brian Cawley

  Sheriff Herald
• 
  Alexya Garcia

  Townsfolk
• 
  India Conner

  Servant
• 
  Patrick Donovan

  Huckleberry Finn
• 
  Jack Reid

  School Boy
• 
  Isabelle McGilvray

  School Girl
• 
  Leeloo Hellie

  Sid Sawyer