• 
  Will Forte

  Himself - Bachelor Fan (archive footage)
• 
  Lea Michele

  Herself - Bachelor Fan (archive footage)
• 
  Chris Harrison

  Himself - Host
• 
  Trista Rehn

  Herself
• 
  Paul Scheer

  Himself (as Paul Sheer)
• 
  Ryan Sutter

  Himself (as Ryan)
• 
  Andrew Firestone

  Himself
• 
  Amy Schumer

  Herself - Bachelor Fan (archive footage)

• 
  Michelle Money

  Herself
• 
  Ali Fedotowsky

  Herself
• 
  Chris Bukowski

  Himself
• 
  Chris Soules

  Himself
• 
  Kaitlyn Bristowe

  Herself
• 
  Shawn Booth

  Himself
• 
  Ben Higgins

  Himself