• 
  Lexi Dripps

  Michelle
• 
  Rik Billock

  The Preacher
• 
  Ari Lehman

  Dr. Rock
• 
  James Weldon

  Mr. Daniels
• 
  Nikki Howell

  Nikki
• 
  Dakota Corwin

  Hootenanny Guest #9
• 
  Justin M. Seaman

  Boogeyman
• 
  Brian Gault

  Brian Hucklebuck-Drums (Legendary Hucklebucks)

• 
  Jon Bailey

  Less Grain (voice)
• 
  Elyse Alberts

  Matt's Older Sister
• 
  Mitchell Musolino

  Sam
• 
  Maggi Mizell

  Hallowed Jack
• 
  Michael Prutzman

  Hootenanny Guest #19
• 
  David Hampton

  George
• 
  Cheyenne Burnsworth

  Arcade Kid #1

• 
  Colton Burnsworth

  Roller Rink Patron #2
• 
  Cortland Woodard

  Chris
• 
  Will Stout

  Josh
• 
  Nickolaus Joshua

  Russell
• 
  Maggi Mizell

  Hallowed Jack
• 
  Jonathan Vertosick

  Hootenanny guest #1
• 
  Robert Mizell

  Candycorn Scarecrow
• 
  Nicholas Sprowls

  Terrorized Trick or Treater
• 
  Dave Fresch

  Dave Fresch-Guitar (Legendary Hucklebucks)
• 
  Ryan Nogy

  Shirley Garrett
• 
  Linda Emeterio

  Old Cat Lady
• 
  Ted Boyko

  Ted Bundy-Vocals (Legendary Hucklebucks)
• 
  Johnny Relich

  Johnny Devil-Guitar (Legendary Hucklebucks)
• 
  Douglas Sikora

  Uncle Piddles-Upright Bass (Legendary Hucklebucks)
• 
  Nikki Howell

  Nikki (as Nikki Darling)
• 
  Hunter Amos

  George Haywin (child)
• 
  Linnea Quigley

  Ms. Barnhart
• 
  James Baker

  Ash Baxtor
• 
  Matt Starr Bores

  Vinny Michaels