• 
  Clay Evans

   Hank Jackson (10 episodes, 2012)
• 
  Jeanne Whitney

   Lindsey DuPree (10 episodes, 2012)
• 
  Kevin Roach

   Benjamin Dolerman (8 episodes, 2012)
• 
  Julie Pyle

   Andrea Wallace (6 episodes, 2012)
• 
  Rusty James

   Grant Hammel (6 episodes, 2012)
• 
  Benjamin Crockett

   Dallas McKay (10 episodes, 2012)
• 
  Kristine Renee Farley

  God
• 
  David Ross

  St. Peter

• 
  Joe Atkinson

  Tony Roman
• 
  Jakob Bilinski

  John Osmond
• 
  Andy Smith

  Bible Study Classmate
• 
  Amber Acton

  Protestor
• 
  Michael Joseph Armanno

  Religious Representative
• 
  Erin Atkinson

  Female Voice 2
• 
  Will Atkinson

  Bible Study Classmate

• 
  Mohammad Azarian

  Religious Representative
• 
  Mackenzie Bilinski

  Female Voice 1
• 
  Mark Clem

  James Lander
• 
  Toby Onwumere

  Empty Suit
• 
  Patrick Higgs

  Anchor 5
• 
  Cindy Maples

  Dani
• 
  Timothy Paul Taylor

  Protestor
• 
  Louie Lawless

  Dale Mirano
• 
  Alicia Harris

  Bible Study Classmate
• 
  P.J. Starks

  Angry Fat Man