• 
  Hallie Bulleit

  Herself
• 
  Chris Gethard

  Himself - Host
• 
  Shannon Patricia O'Neill

  Panelist (as Shannon O'Neill)
• 
  Andrew K. Meyer

  Random Andrew
• 
  Bethany Hall

  Panelist
• 
  Robert Malone

  Himself
• 
  David Bluvband

  Human Fish
• 
  Jason Eppink

  40 Year Old Goosey

• 
  Ellen Mangan

  Random Ellen
• 
  Mimi Fischer

  Mimi on the Hoops
• 
  Murf Meyer

  Panelist
• 
  Kelsey Murphy

  Herself
• 
  Bill Florio

  Himself
• 
  Mal Blum

  Herself
• 
  Sabrina Fonfeder

  Herself