• 
  Chris Gethard

  Himself - Host
• 
  Dan Black

  Dan Black, The Guy Who Fucking Hates The Chris Gethard Show
• 
  Pat Baer

  Watermelon Cop
• 
  Ken Beck

  Vinegar Al
• 
  Bethany Hall

  Panelist
• 
  David Bluvband

  Human Fish
• 
  Dru Johnston

  El însuși
• 
  Langan Kingsley

  Writer Who Was Fired From The New Yorker For Being Too Pretentious

• 
  Ellen Mangan

  Random Ellen
• 
  Brandon Gulya

  The Guy Who Likes Cream But Not Too Much Cream
• 
  Matt Dennie

  Mopey Janitor with Bad Timing and A Broken Mop
• 
  Diana Kolsky

  Audience Member with a Sleeping Baby
• 
  Mimi Fischer

  Mimi on the Hoops
• 
  Murf Meyer

  Panelist
• 
  Jesse Lee

  Lil Woody Allen

• 
  Ken Beck

  Vinegar Al