• 
  Lance Henry

  Detective Lacy
• 
  Cara Cochran

  Jennifer Ryan (rumored)
• 
  Lindsay Slott

  Dr. Stacy Braddock (rumored)
• 
  Chris Mayo

  Officer Brady
• 
  Nick W. Nicholson

  Captain Logan (rumored)
• 
  Elizabeth Redpath

  Amy Cooper (rumored)
• 
  Carl Bailey

  John Eden
• 
  Drew Brown

  Detective Murray

• 
  Lauren Leal

  Darcy Kelly (rumored)
• 
  Troy Parker

  Shawn Camden
• 
  Jennifer Rogers

  Young Margaret (rumored)
• 
  Mark Docherty

  Fisher
• 
  Elizabeth Lestina

  Jamie Miller (rumored)
• 
  Anita Darby

  Old Margaret
• 
  Keavy Bradley

  Emma Miller

• 
  Bailey Vaughn McAndrew

  Suzy
• 
  Sarah McSpadden

  Catherine Miller
• 
  Elvis Clark

  Nick
• 
  Ian Haywood

  Officer Hill
• 
  Sandra Nicole Wilson

  Rebecca King (rumored)
• 
  John Maciag

  Detective Thompson
• 
  Sheri Oster

  Brooke Foster (rumored)
• 
  Gilbert Hiracheta

  Chauffeur