• 
  Zach Kepple

  Lester
• 
  Stephanie Wulfe

  Real Estate Agent
• 
  Carson Nicely

  Michael
• 
  Skyy Moore

  Jared
• 
  John Cawthon

  Lester Father
• 
  Matthew Munoz

  Lester (Age 10)
• 
  Lance De Los Santos

  Detective
• 
  Miranda Parham

  Lana

• 
  Tiffany Griffin

  Molly
• 
  Rodney Osborne

  Eddie Osborne
• 
  Canon Buckingham

  Will
• 
  Gay Hunter

  Lester Mother
• 
  David Skinner

  Bully Adult
• 
  James DeArmond

  Tommy
• 
  David Hayes

  Squid

• 
  Jimmy Lee Kelley

  AC Repair Man
• 
  Elizabeth McGrath

  Leslie
• 
  Stacy Krumholz

  Ghostly Presence / Bully's Wife