• 
  Lionel Strasky

  1 episode
• 
  Lee Raviv

  1 episode
• 
  Nathan Roberts

  1 episode
• 
  Stephanie Schildknecht

  1 episode
• 
  Karin Howard

  2 episodes, 2018
• 
  Paula Tiso

  6 episodes, 2018
• 
  Dominique Maher

  2 episodes, 2018-2019
• 
  Candice van Litsenborgh

  Eva

• 
  Doug Atkin

  Self - Missy's Father
• 
  Ken Atkin

  Self - Missy's Brother
• 
  Linda Atkin

  Self - Missy's Mother
• 
  Eve Barger

  Self - Scott Reynolds Ex-Girlfriend
• 
  Vanessa Brierley

  Lisa Richman
• 
  Bryant Gregory

  Self - Det., Rutherford County TN Sheriff's Office
• 
  Troy Hooker

  Self - Det., Rutherford County TN Sheriff's Office

• 
  Marcia Kautz

  Self - Missy's Friend
• 
  Ralph Mayercik

  Self - Det., Rutherford County TN Sheriff's Office
• 
  William Whitesell Jr.

  Self - District Attorney (ret.)
• 
  Donzella Anuszkiewicz

  Self - Margo's Friend
• 
  Cheryl Brown

  Self - Robin's Sister
• 
  Sean Cameron Michael

  Detective Cleveland
• 
  Arthur Falko

  Brian Thompson
• 
  Terri Lane

  Carla Smith