• 
  Christian E. Christiansen

  regizor

• 
  Adelaide Kane

  Ruth
• 
  Alycia Debnam-Carey

  Mary
• 
  Leah Pipes

  Sarah
• 
  Rufus Sewell

  Jacob Brown
• 
  Andrea Alcorn

  Amish Villager
• 
  Caitlin Alexa Hall

  Villager
• 
  Cassidy Layden

  Amish Villager

• 
  Christopher Cozort

  Villager
• 
  Colm Meaney

  Elder Beacon
• 
  Darrell Rackley

  Village elder
• 
  Dennis Layden

  Amish Villager
• 
  Drew Grey

  Frank
• 
  Ethan Alexander McGee

  Thomas
• 
  George Bryant II

  Doctor

• 
  Grace Layden

  Amish Villager
• 
  Holli Saperstein

  Midwife
• 
  James Alcorn

  Amish Villiager
• 
  Jane McNeill

  Sarah's mother
• 
  Jennifer Carpenter

  Rebekah
• 
  Jim McKeny

  Elder Stone
• 
  Jim Prim

  Villager
• 
  Joe Montanti

  Town Local
• 
  Jon Stafford

  Ruth's Dad
• 
  Kathy Walton Pulley

  Midwife
• 
  Katie Garfield

  Abby
• 
  Laura Avery

  Amish Villager
• 
  Martin Petersen

  Town Elder
• 
  Meagan Hall

  Villager
• 
  Melissa Lozoff

  Hannah's Mom
• 
  Meredith Jackson

  Villager
• 
  Merideth Harrison

  Villager
• 
  Michael D. Layden

  Amish Villager
• 
  Nicole Elliott

  Hannah
• 
  Paul Shaplin

  Village Elder
• 
  Quentin Kerr

  Sherriff's Deputy
• 
  Ric Reitz

  Sheriff Stevens
• 
  Robin Dale Robertson

  Tobias Maker
• 
  Stacy Rabon

  Ruth's Mom
• 
  Stephen Elliott

  Villager
• 
  Taran Hall

  Villager
• 
  Thomas McDonell

  Trevor
• 
  Zachary Steffey

  Party Goer

• 
  Mickey Liddell

  producător
• 
  Jennifer Monroe

  producător
• 
  Pete Shilaimon

  producător
• 
  Paddy Cullen

  producător executiv
• 
  Scott Holroyd

  producător executiv
• 
  Michael Zelman

  producător executiv