• 
  Jaysen P. Buterin

  Cult Leader (as Jaysen Buterin)
• 
  John Dondero

  Chuck
• 
  Blair Hoyle

  Jeffrey Hawthorne
• 
  Lucky Mangione

  The Lettuce Man
• 
  Dave Harlequin

  Bouncer
• 
  J.C. Kingsley

  Detective Richard Johnson
• 
  Nev Kelly

  Father Harold Jones
• 
  Garrett Mooneyhan

  Steve

• 
  Charles Baldwin

  Cultist #1 (as Charles 'Torch' Baldwin)
• 
  Chris Baldwin

  Cultist #4
• 
  Ricky McWaters

  The Narrator
• 
  Hannah Scott-Collins

  Allie
• 
  Charlie

  Rabbitus Jr.
• 
  Hollie Rode

  Cultist #2
• 
  Danny Phoenix

  Rabbitus Prime