• 
  Steve Eastin

  Gordon
• 
  Joe Grifasi

  Dr. Bradley
• 
  Chad Crenshaw

  Party Goer
• 
  Jesse Nathan

  The Poet
• 
  Sophia Savage

  Marie DiPierro
• 
  Darwin Luján

  Jim LaPish
• 
  Jake Smith

  Rene Sendam
• 
  Nicholas D. Johnson

  Rhodus

• 
  Jim Ramos

  Bob
• 
  Greg Lane

  Pastor
• 
  Becca Huerter

  Sandra Saucedo
• 
  Ashley Kennedy

  Autumn
• 
  Towns Windholz

  Rene Sendam (5 Years)
• 
  Nico Yoch

  Rolando
• 
  Micah Small

  Maggie

• 
  Myka Small

  Rene's Mother
• 
  Danielle L. Hodges

  Cake Eater
• 
  Shai Jackson

  Cake Eater
• 
  Ashley Spring

  Dancer
• 
  Tony Ontiveros

  Church Member
• 
  Jeff Staab

  Well-Dressed Man
• 
  Natalie Edmondson

  Student
• 
  Austin Wagoner

  Party Guy
• 
  Jennifer Bennett

  Rene's School Teacher
• 
  Kalee Forsythe

  Cake Eater
• 
  Gabriela Martínez de Velasco

  Church Member
• 
  Mason Finley

  Bouncer
• 
  Zachary Mastrosimone

  Teen Rene
• 
  Kristin Rea

  Kelly
• 
  Tony Backus

  Himself
• 
  Robert Hubbard

  Church Member
• 
  Kiley Chavez

  Church Member
• 
  Carmen Dacosta

  Cake Eater
• 
  Erik Blume

  Band (keyboard)
• 
  Jackson Reed

  Awkward Man
• 
  Aaron Linscheid

  Band (trumpet)
• 
  Brett Jackson

  Band (saxophone)
• 
  Andrew Vincent Soloducha

  Bouncer
• 
  Krystin Arkeketa

  Cake Eater
• 
  Homer Zerger

  Church Member
• 
  Cecilia Backus

  Cake Eater
• 
  Cameron DuPratte

  Bartender
• 
  Frank Borror

  Church Member
• 
  Ann Zerger

  The Sculptor