• 
  Kristin Keating

  Miriam
• 
  Haidyn Harvey

  Kate
• 
  Christine Mascolo

  Mary
• 
  Kasha Fauscett

  Sarah
• 
  Andy Hankins

  Martin
• 
  Chris Green

  Irene
• 
  Kevin Sean Ryan

  Jon
• 
  Mark Mook

  Marvin

• 
  Christy McIntyre

  Amanda
• 
  Jasmine Fauscett

  Young Sarah
• 
  Sage Porter

  Vanessa
• 
  Ben Voloch

  Amish Bully
• 
  Becky Nutt

  Ashley (as Becky Nutt)
• 
  Erica Young

  Maggie
• 
  Megan Richie

  Becky

• 
  McAlyn Forbes

  Barb
• 
  Wesley Juels

  Samuel
• 
  Parker Juels

  Amos
• 
  Jaime Ciarla

  Verena
• 
  Sam Wickey

  Jake
• 
  Bella Motter

  Ester Wickey
• 
  Taylor Poyfair

  Tina / Bully
• 
  Becky Nutt

  Ashley
• 
  Reed Haymons

  Little Samuel
• 
  Cassandra Perkins

  Marie
• 
  Michael Simpson

  Yoni
• 
  Hawley Pen

  Girl on bus
• 
  Allie Taylor

  Esther
• 
  Madison Schweitz

  Emma
• 
  Conner Falk

  Young Amos (as Conner Falk)
• 
  Brooke Bowman

  Young Barb
• 
  Emily Seracuse

  Anny
• 
  Mireya Zellner

  Young Emma
• 
  Catherine Bowman

  Young Marie