• 
  Vincent Price

  Clifford Pyncheon
• 
  Cecil Kellaway

  Philip Barton
• 
  Kernan Cripps

  Workman
• 
  Gilbert Emery

  Gerald Pyncheon
• 
  Russ Powell

  Grocer/Juror
• 
  Colin Kenny

  Court Bailiff
• 
  Edgar Norton

  Phineas Weed, Jaffrey's Servant
• 
  Alan Napier

  Fuller, the Postman

• 
  George Sanders

  Jaffrey Pyncheon
• 
  Margaret Lindsay

  Hepzibah Pyncheon
• 
  Miles Mander

  Deacon Arnold Foster
• 
  Dick Foran

  Matthew Maule
• 
  Harry Cording

  Blacksmith Hawkins
• 
  Caroline Cooke

  Town Gossip
• 
  Margaret Fealy

  Town Gossip

• 
  Harry Stubbs

  Jeremiah - Man in Pub
• 
  Charles Trowbridge

  Judecător