• 
  Denise Cheseldine

  Townsperson
• 
  Mark Falvo

  Cowboy
• 
  Johnny Alonso

  Mr. Jones
• 
  Peter Wray

  Preacher Brent Carson
• 
  Walker Hays

  May
• 
  Kendra North

  Sister Francis Barnes
• 
  Antoinette Greene-Fisher

  Alice Barnaby
• 
  Nina Fowler

  Saloon Girl

• 
  Paul Wiedecker

  Mr. Mitchell
• 
  Colin McHugh

  Jonah Carson
• 
  Christopher Inlow

  Carter Dodson
• 
  Evelyn Manchester

  Mary
• 
  Chris Conlon

  Cowboy
• 
  Catalina Parks

  Angelica Gomez
• 
  Donald Imm

  Mike McCray

• 
  Velta Moore

  Saloon Girl
• 
  Lamont Easter

  Bill Barnaby
• 
  Joanna M. Lewis

  Townsperson
• 
  Kelly Schwartz

  Elizabeth Turner
• 
  James Matthew Poole

  Joshua Carson (as James Poole)
• 
  Vivian Yoon Lee

  Jasmine
• 
  Vaughn Bullard

  Cody
• 
  Caleb McDaniel

  Johnny
• 
  Sofia Pellegrino

  Saloon Girl
• 
  Christa A. Feldi

  Saloon girl
• 
  Matthew Beagan

  Young Joshua
• 
  Evelyn Hale-Kupiec

  Towns Person
• 
  Pat Jones

  Church Member