• 
  Carly Pope

  Angela Cady
• 
  Bryan Greenberg

  Dylan Cady
• 
  Alyssa Sutherland

  Dana Cady
• 
  Michael Gladis

  Michael Kennedy
• 
  William R. Moses

  Principal Mullins
• 
  Jim True-Frost

  Pastor Shane
• 
  Ryan Joseph Long

  Carnival Patron / Student
• 
  William Popp

  Deputy Johnson

• 
  Jance Enslin

  Andy Cady
• 
  Alison Thornton

  Bethany Forrest
• 
  Remington Moses

  Melanie Hansen
• 
  Nathan Wallace

  Paul Winters
• 
  J.T. Romagnoli

  Student ,Church Goer, Swim Team member
• 
  Blaine Maye

  Brian Ward
• 
  Allen Wall

  Freak at the Carnival

• 
  Bernie Sheredy

  Dr. Roger Wagner
• 
  Rachel Kaminsky

  Reporter
• 
  Kevin Alan Wall

  Carnival Freak
• 
  Jude Washock

  Student
• 
  Quinn Hemphill

  Amber
• 
  Daniel Rayome

  Fairgoer
• 
  Dannielle Rose

  Religious Woman
• 
  Jill Mack

  Background Extra
• 
  Amber Anne

  Church Choir / Swim Team
• 
  Nicole McDonald

  Blogger (credit only)
• 
  Scott Matheny

  State Trooper
• 
  Christine Lauer

  Church Goer
• 
  Wayne W. Johnson

  Church Goer