• 
  Jay Dunigan

   Jack (2020-)
• 
  David Pridemore

   Fallon's Victim (2020-)
• 
  Charles Linshaw

   Uncle Dominic
• 
  Lyralen Kaye

   Reagan Esposito
• 
  Zele Avradopoulos

   Dr. Matthias
• 
  Caitlin Graham

   Fallon Eposito
• 
  Michael Indeglio

   Michael Esposito
• 
  Paul Meredith

   Iggy Esposito

• 
  Victoria George

   Sasha
• 
  Koko Ekong

   Darren
• 
  Cady Walls

   Young Fallon (2019)
• 
  Ryan Hagan

   Teen Dominic (2019)
• 
  Connor Murray

   Teen Manhunt Player (2019)
• 
  Ava Lyons

   Churchgoer (2020-)
• 
  Andrea Lyman

   Child Psychologist (2020-)

• 
  Jon Pierce

   Bill (2020-)
• 
  Diana Oh

   Phoenix (2020-)
• 
  Cheryl Singleton

   Dr. Matthias (2020-)
• 
  Alec Carstoiu

   Manhunt Kid #5 (2020-)
• 
  Danny Bolton

  Jer (2020-)
• 
  Asher Navisky

  Young Michael (2020-)
• 
  Eli Dresser

  Manhunt Kid #2 (2020-)
• 
  Margaret Wissiup

  Diner patron #2
• 
  Daniel Boudreau

  Man in Michael's Nightmare (2020-)
• 
  Rosalind Thomas-Clark

  Churchgoer (2020-)
• 
  Cindy Ecclesiastre

  Manhunt Kid #4 (2020-)
• 
  Elizabeth Navisky

  Churchgoer (2020-)
• 
  W. Richard Johnson

  Churchgoer (2020-)
• 
  Charles Brown

  Churchgoer (2020-)