• 
  Steve Agee

  Himself
• 
  Dawn Cody

  Herself
• 
  Jeff Bryan Davis

  Himself - Host (as Jeff Davis)
• 
  Michael McCafferty

  Himself (as Mike McCafferty)
• 
  Derek Mears

  Himself
• 
  Chris Tallman

  Himself
• 
  Rob Schrab

  Himself
• 
  Dan Harmon

  Himself

• 
  Matt Braunger

  Himself
• 
  Chris Romano

  Himself (as Romanski) (credit only)
• 
  J.D. Ryznar

  Himself
• 
  Ryan Ridley

  Himself
• 
  Abed Gheith

  Himself
• 
  Mike Rose

  Himself
• 
  Aaron Moles

  Himself