• 
  Clarence Felder

  Edgar P Sawyer
• 
  Courtney Gains

  Tug Wilson
• 
  Richard Herd

  Mr. Beagle
• 
  Sam J. Jones

  Jacob Hoy
• 
  Kathleen Kinmont

  Mrs. McCall
• 
  Barry Livingston

  Frank Selee
• 
  Anne Lockhart

  Mrs. Hart
• 
  Tyler Mane

  Tommy McCarthy

• 
  Barry Pearl

  Milwaukee Owner
• 
  Andy Stahl

  John Lowery
• 
  Marshall R. Teague

  Dooley
• 
  Vernon Wells

  Sarah's Father
• 
  Sheree J. Wilson

  Rebecca Hoy
• 
  Bill Billions

  Milwaukee Manager
• 
  Robbie Allen

  Pope

• 
  Lea Hutton Beasmore

  Train Station Pedestrian
• 
  Jody Stevenson

  Anna
• 
  Miles Barbee

  William 'Dummy' Hoy
• 
  Christian Hetrick

  Con Murphy
• 
  Kate Sanford

  Ruth Murphy
• 
  Ani Kyd Wolf

  Sarah's mother
• 
  John Cioffi

  Reds Player
• 
  Mark White

  Doorman
• 
  Chad Fuller

  Barber / Umpire
• 
  James Stokes

  Umpire
• 
  Richard Leo Hunt

  Milwaukee Pitcher
• 
  Michael Loos

  Milwaukee Centerfielder