• 
  Leonard Nimoy

  Wismer
• 
  DeForest Kelley

  Lt. Beldon
• 
  Lee J. Cobb

  Judge Henry Garth
• 
  Stewart Bradley

  Sheriff
• 
  Robert Brubaker

  Major Herbert
• 
  William Bryant

  Paul Judson
• 
  Barry Cahill

  Mr. Pierce
• 
  Gary Clarke

  Steve Hill

• 
  James Drury

  The Virginian
• 
  Jim Goodwin

  Corp. Perkins
• 
  Peggy McCay

  Helen Hammond Judson
• 
  Doug McClure

  Trampas
• 
  Michael Pate (I)

  Mike McGoff
• 
  Ann Prentiss

  Alice (as Ann Gardner)
• 
  Harry Shannon

  Uncle Josh