• 
  Kevin Lingle

  Jim
• 
  Erin O'Shea

  1920s Woman
• 
  Sasha Rossof

  Victorian Girl
• 
  Jennifer Betancourt

  1970s Woman
• 
  Maisie Merlock

  Teen Sam
• 
  Amy Rapp

  Adult Sam
• 
  Clare O'Connor

  College Sam
• 
  Rose Sengenberger

  Offscreen Voice #1 (voice)

• 
  Becca Levine

  Aunt Sue
• 
  Joe Page

  1940s Man
• 
  Jennifer Cudahy

  Nola
• 
  Sabrina Smith

  Hannah
• 
  Sophia Ntovas

  Offscreen Voice #2 (voice)
• 
  Autumn Bell

  Young Sam
• 
  Theo Shuler

  Offscreen Voice #3 (voice)