• 
  Peter Arnold

  Inmate
• 
  Wiley B. Oscar

  God
• 
  B.J. Lucas

  Saint Peter
• 
  Kenney Selvey

  Saint Matt
• 
  Sean Small

  Hell Patron
• 
  Meredith Michalojko

  Clarissa
• 
  Samantha Veil

  Mary
• 
  Sam Platt

  Joseph

• 
  Sarah Serio

  Emma
• 
  Jared Wernick

  Mark
• 
  Paige Snyder

  Hell Receptionist
• 
  Paul Hird

  Lucifer
• 
  Shaunte Tabb

  Party Patron
• 
  Katie Anne Moy

  Stacy
• 
  Sharifa Oliver

  Alice

• 
  Reed Iacarella

  Shirtless Party Patron
• 
  Christine Buccelli

  Party Patron
• 
  Danielle Baez

  Spa Girl
• 
  Brett Takeshita

  Bartender
• 
  Laura Lee Walsh

  Attractive Woman
• 
  Rachel Addington

  Leah
• 
  Lexi Eiserman

  Gods Assistant
• 
  Marisa Moreno

  Party Patron
• 
  Ariel Thompson

  Nurse
• 
  Jacklyn Robinson

  Fan Girl
• 
  Eric Michael Johnson

  Jesus (as Eric Johnson)
• 
  Sammi Johnson

  Counselor
• 
  Colleen Glennon

  Heaven Gallery Patron
• 
  Steven Kellogg

  Grim
• 
  Josh Inman

  Weed Man
• 
  Charles Kinder

  Shirtless Party Patron
• 
  Ross Gray

  Soccer Player
• 
  Gareth Lindo

  Soccer Player
• 
  Katie Howard

  Spa Girl
• 
  Bryce Lourié

  Moses
• 
  Jose Luis Magaña

  Coffee Shop Barista