• 
  Kristen Johnston

  Esmerelda
• 
  Tim Decker

  Ben Perry
• 
  Philip E. Johnson

  Officer Karaffa
• 
  Tim Kazurinsky

  Gus
• 
  Mark Lancaster

  Pirate Angus
• 
  Helen Sadler

  Aubrey
• 
  Andy Luther

  Sal
• 
  Matt Kozlowski

  Mike

• 
  Sarah Benedict

  Reporter
• 
  Aidan Traynor

  Bully Larry
• 
  Paul Lang

  Al Capone
• 
  Ira Amyx

  Drake
• 
  Michael B. Woods

  Pirate Chang (as Michael Woods)
• 
  John Babbo

  Truman
• 
  Stephen A. Salemi

  Nicky

• 
  Trevor Fahnstrom

  Bully Cliff
• 
  JJ Phillips

  Chip
• 
  Nicole Scimeca

  Lainey Perry
• 
  Clare O'Connor

  Heather
• 
  Michael Saguto

  Mike
• 
  Lucas Jade Zumann

  Henry Perry
• 
  Tori Tellschow

  Joy Perry
• 
  Sophia Ntovas

  Debbie
• 
  Janaan Rose

  Witch
• 
  Frank Wiltse

  Police Captain
• 
  Aurora Adachi-Winter

  Island Woman #1
• 
  Chris Brickhouse

  Riot Officer #1