• 
  Armando Valdes-Kennedy

  Narrator
• 
  Brandon McKinnie

  Elgin Ray Robinson Jr.
• 
  Antonia Carlotta

  Chelsea Brooks
• 
  Darin Brooks

  Himself - Chelsea's Father
• 
  Vivian Kerr

  Amanda Howard
• 
  Lisa Boesky

  Herself - Psychologist / Author
• 
  Evan Brooks

  Himself - Chelsea's Brother
• 
  Terri Brooks

  Herself - Chelsea's Mother

• 
  Jim Kanatzer

  Himself - Jackson County Prosecuter
• 
  Amy Francis

  Herself - Chelsea's Friend
• 
  Patrick Anderson

  Himself - Writer
• 
  Christine Funk

  Herself - Nicole's Defense Attorney
• 
  Kevin Hoffman

  Himself - Journalist
• 
  Joe Grappoli

  Himself - Investigator
• 
  Andrea Brooks

  Herself - Chelsea's Sister