• 
  Heather Reusz

  Heather
• 
  Aiyanna Wade

  Aiyanna
• 
  Walter Banasiak

   Himself / ... (18 episodes, 2016)
• 
  James Jarosz

  Jim
• 
  Doug Walker

  Nostalgia Critic
• 
  Rob Walker

  Dino Rob
• 
  Tamara Chambers

  Tamara
• 
  Malcolm Ray

  Malcolm

• 
  Bryan Porter

  Bryan
• 
  Barney Walker

  Barney
• 
  Michael Lablanca

  Michael
• 
  Matt Mikka

  Matt
• 
  Ryan Grino

  Ryan
• 
  HelloGreedo

  Self
• 
  Anthony LaBanca

  Anthony

• 
  Brad Jones

  Brad
• 
  Alyssamay Griño

  Alyssamay
• 
  Jennifer Reusz

  Heather Reusz