• 
  John Lithgow

  Larry Henderson
• 
  Nicholas D'Agosto

  Josh Simon
• 
  Del Hunter-White

   Waitress (1 episode, 2016)
• 
  Sherri Shepherd

  Anne Flatch
• 
  Angel Parker

   Heidi Baker (1 episode, 2016)
• 
  Jayma Mays

  Carol Anne Keane
• 
  Steven Boyer

   Dwayne (1 episode, 2016)
• 
  Krysta Rodriguez

   Summer Henderson (1 episode, 2016)

• 
  AJ Achinger

   Airline Rep (1 episode, 2016)
• 
  Cristine Rose

   Josie Davis (1 episode, 2016)
• 
  Jason Boggs

   Errol (1 episode, 2016)
• 
  Clint Culp

   Bailiff (1 episode, 2016)
• 
  Bob Gunton

   Jeremiah Davis (1 episode, 2016)
• 
  Afsheen Olyaie

   Court Attendee (2 episodes, 2016)
• 
  Fred Melamed

   Howard Mankiewicz (2 episodes, 2017)

• 
  Ervin Ross

   Clarence (2 episodes, 2017)
• 
  Patricia Belcher

   Judge... (7 episodes, 2017)
• 
  John Hartman

   Mitchell (3 episodes, 2017)
• 
  David A. Garcia

   Juror #8 (4 episodes, 2017)
• 
  Loretta Shenosky

   Edna / ... (6 episodes, 2017)
• 
  Dave Allen

  Dave the Taxidermist
• 
  Lorna Scott

  Suzie
• 
  Kristin Chenoweth

  10 episodes, 2018
• 
  Amanda Payton

  10 episodes, 2018
• 
  Lauren McGibbon

  10 episodes, 2018
• 
  Joel McCrary

  10 episodes, 2018
• 
  Michael Hitchcock

  Jesse Ray Beaumont
• 
  Peter Ciuffa

  Bailiff