• 
  Joe Ferrell

  Joe Andrews
• 
  Liz Kaar

  Curler 1
• 
  Atra Asdou

  Chicago Boss
• 
  Liz Harvey

  Liz
• 
  Jake Myers

  Thorn
• 
  Ben Kobold

  Cab driver
• 
  Leland

  Dog
• 
  Bobby Budds

  Comedian 1

• 
  Tyler Snodgrass

  Comedian 2
• 
  Will Flanagan

  Will Buscher
• 
  Nick Aiello

  Nick Buscher
• 
  Joe Ferrell

  Joe Andrews
• 
  Heidi Cheek

  Heidi
• 
  John Myers

  John Buscher
• 
  Lucy Flanagan

  Party Guest and Bar Patron

• 
  Bryan Kveton

  Party Guest 8
• 
  Aaron Stone

  Ice Cream Boy
• 
  Traci Van Laarhoven Myers

  Mrs. Buscher
• 
  Ben Magnuson

  Chicago Coworker 1
• 
  John Davies

  Rural Bar Patron 2
• 
  Jeremiah Myers

  Curler and Party Guest
• 
  Eli Coyote Mandel

  Triumph Coworker 1 (as Eli Mandel)
• 
  Casey Ochs

  Party Guest 2
• 
  Patrick Jenkins

  Party Guest 7
• 
  Jason Folks

  Comedian 3
• 
  Toni Van Laarhoven

  Nick & Will's Aunt
• 
  Myles Armstrong

  Myles the Bartender
• 
  Emily Allman

  Party Guest 4
• 
  Matt Cunningham

  Gump's friend Matt
• 
  Ben Cannon

  Triumph Coworker 2
• 
  Garret Bodette

  Party Guest 5
• 
  Brittany Culkowski

  Party Guest 6
• 
  Kevin Bretz

  Rural Bar Patron 1
• 
  Shawn Flickinger

  Triumph Coworker 3