• 
  Tim Simon

   Tim (7 episodes)
• 
  Seth Landau

   Jim (6 episodes)
• 
  Sarah Mozeson

  Jane Jane Janet
• 
  Matt Simon

  Clarence
• 
  Casey Kozlowski

  Mr. Kozlowski
• 
  Ezra Lewis

  Chode
• 
  Drew Beck

  Dad
• 
  Neruda Williams

  Donny

• 
  Thomas Countz

  Tomas Del Vino
• 
  Maxwell Hegley

  Paper Boy
• 
  Brittany Lee McDonald

  Nut Butters Lady
• 
  Matt Rubin

  Two Tims Fan
• 
  Xander Zellner

  Ezra
• 
  Sean Girton

  Irish Man
• 
  Siobhan O'Hara

  Audience Member

• 
  Nick Reichheld

  Nice Guy
• 
  Jesse Roth

  Tina