• 
  Scott duPont

  2 episodes
• 
  Aundrea Smith

  2 episodes, 2019
• 
  Stuart Todd Martin

  2 episodes, 2018
• 
  Mark Krenik

  3 episodes
• 
  Yoying Eng

  2 episodes
• 
  Jessica Dowdeswell

  2 episodes, 2019
• 
  Akyra Alihaah Carter

  2 episodes
• 
  Andrea L Gavidia

  2 episodes

• 
  Colt Carville

  Justin
• 
  Maralyn Facey

  Mother Edna
• 
  Patrick West

  Self - Lead Investigator, North Ridgeville PD
• 
  Chelsea Lorraine Wargo

  Laura Finkle
• 
  Suzanne Stratford

  Self - TV Reporter, WJW News
• 
  Danusia Tyburski

  Self - Shelly and Hannah's Grandmother
• 
  Audrey Jablosnki

  Self - Family Friend

• 
  Lauren Jablonski

  Self - Shelly's Friend
• 
  Chelsea Nicol

  Self - Shelly's Friend
• 
  Greg Petek

  Self - Lieutenant, North Ridgeville PD
• 
  Jerry Rector

  Richard Haltstead