• 
  Chace Crawford

  Barone
• 
  Joseph Mazzello

  Pat Murray
• 
  Manny Montana

  Zapata
• 
  Jim Belushi

  Jim
• 
  Robert Curtis Brown

  Brian Murray
• 
  Michael Fishman

  Antonelli
• 
  Tyler Hoechlin

  Dells
• 
  Philip Winchester

  Fotch

• 
  Billy Gardell

  Umpire Haze
• 
  Matt Barr

  Anthony
• 
  Ryan Pinkston

  Jonathan Garvey
• 
  Toby Hemingway

  Palacco
• 
  Matt Bush

  David
• 
  Jay Hayden

  Vinnie
• 
  David Del Rio

  Tree

• 
  Aaron Tveit

  John Mazetti
• 
  Casey Bond

  Tommy Dorehty
• 
  Duke Davis Roberts

  Ty Dellamonica
• 
  Mary Elizabeth Runyon

  Barone's Girlfriend
• 
  Michael Bunin

  Officer Redmond (rumored)